Comprehensive Guide to Life, Mortgage, and Disability Insurance

Your home is likely your most valuable asset, a symbol of stability and security for you and your family. When purchasing a home, it’s natural to wonder how best to protect this crucial investment. As a homeowner, you have two main options to consider:

1. Take out mortgage insurance
2. Protect your mortgage with a life insurance policy

In addition to one of these options, you might also consider taking out disability insurance.  This article will explore the differences between these three insurance products and help you determine which one might best protect your home and family.

First, it’s important to clarify the distinction between mortgage loan insurance, such as that offered by  the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC), and the other types of insurance mentioned. Mortgage loan insurance protects the lender (not the borrower) in case the borrower defaults. The cost of this insurance ranges between 0.6% and 4.5% of the mortgage amount.

I. Mortgage Insurance 

Mortgage insurance protects against payment defaults. It is easier to obtain than conventional life insurance. As the mortgage insurance premium is calculated based on a percentage of the loan, if the loan rate increases, the insurance cost also rises. Moreover, mortgage insurance coverage ends when the loan is repaid.

If you switch financial institutions, you must renegotiate the insurance (the older you get, the less advantageous it becomes). In other words, the premium could increase based on age or health condition, which is not the case with life insurance.

If you pay off the loan in full, your coverage ends. There is no money for your beneficiaries. In the event of death, mortgage insurance only repays the mortgage balance. In other words, the money is entirely paid to the lender. You take out mortgage insurance to ensure your family continues to have a roof over their heads, but in reality, it’s the lender you are protecting.

II. Life Insurance

Life insurance offered by the lender is, for an equivalent amount, more expensive than mortgage insurance. The only constraint is that you will have a much more elaborate questionnaire to fill out and medical exams might be required before your policy comes into effect.

There are three main types of life insurance: term, whole, and universal.

A. Term Life Insurance

The Term Life Insurance (TLI) offers protection for your mortgage as well as financial security for your beneficiaries or loved ones. The amount of your coverage does not decrease over time, even as you pay off your mortgage.

With the TLI, you retain your policy even if you renegotiate or transfer your mortgage to another company. You won’t have to submit any new applications or proof of insurability.

With the TLI, the money goes to your beneficiary or beneficiaries. You choose your beneficiaries, and the value of the mortgage life insurance remains fixed regardless of the term of your contract, whether it’s 15, 20, or 30 years. You also get to choose the duration of the coverage. If your life insurance policy is for $600,000, the person you designated as the beneficiary will receive $600,000 in the event of your death, tax-free. The beneficiary can decide to use this amount to pay off the mortgage, invest it, pay off other debts, or for any other purpose. It’s entirely their decision since they alone will receive the insurance payout.

This flexibility and security make life insurance a smart choice for ensuring that your loved ones are financially protected. Unlike mortgage insurance from a lender, which typically only covers the outstanding balance of your mortgage and pays the lender directly, life insurance gives your beneficiaries control over the funds. This means they can use the money in the way that best meets their needs and circumstances.

B. Whole Life Insurance

Whole life insurance, also known as permanent life insurance, provides coverage for the insured’s entire lifetime, whether they pass away at 35 or 95 years old. As long as the insured maintains the policy, it remains in effect, offering continuous protection.

One of the key features of whole life insurance is that its premiums are generally guaranteed and fixed. Most of the time, this type of insurance also builds cash value, which can be accessed or borrowed against as it accumulates over the years.

Initially, whole life insurance premiums are higher compared to term life insurance. However, whole life insurance offers considerable flexibility in premium payments. For instance, some policies require premium payments for a fixed period rather than throughout your entire life. You might pay premiums for, say, 10 years, and after that period, you owe nothing more. You remain covered for life, but without any additional payments. The insurer, in turn, invests the premiums you pay, which is how they make their profit.

It’s important to note that term life insurance premiums typically increase upon renewal. Over time, these rising costs can make term life insurance more expensive than whole life insurance. Therefore, it’s crucial to assess whether you need coverage for a specific period or for your entire life.

Whole Life Insurance with Participating Features: 

Whole life insurance with participating features, also known as participating life insurance, includes an investment component. Unlike universal life insurance, where you manage the investment portion yourself, the insurer handles it for you with a participating policy.

Because it has an investment aspect, participating life insurance typically costs more than non-participating whole life insurance. The premiums for a participating life insurance policy are fixed for the payment period specified in the contract. The base insurance amount is usually guaranteed, and a cash surrender value can also be included.

Participating life insurance offers a unique blend of guaranteed coverage and potential investment growth. Since the insurer manages the investment, you benefit from professional expertise without the need to actively manage your investments. This hands-off approach can be particularly appealing if you prefer to leave investment decisions to financial experts.

One of the main advantages of participating life insurance is its potential to generate dividends. These dividends can be used to reduce premiums, purchase additional coverage, or even be taken as cash. This flexibility allows you to customize how you use the dividends to best suit your financial needs and goals.

III. Universal Life Insurance

Universal life insurance is a versatile product that combines two key elements of sound financial planning: life insurance protection and a savings account, known as cash value, which grows tax-deferred. This product might be suitable for you if you have no debts and have maximized your contributions to your Registered Retirement Savings Plan (RRSP), Tax-Free Savings Account (TFSA), or Registered Education Savings Plan (RESP).

With universal life insurance, you have the flexibility to decide the amount and timing of your premium payments. Depending on the policy you choose, premiums can either increase with age or remain level. You also get to choose how to invest the accumulated amounts in your policy’s cash value fund.

Your premium payments go into your cash value fund. A portion of your premium covers the cost of your insurance, while any additional amount grows through investments of your choice.

Over the long term, your cash value fund can: (i) pay for the cost of your insurance; (ii) provide for needs in case of a critical illness or disability; or (iii) supplement your retirement income.

You have the option to invest in various types of investments, such as segregated funds. The accumulated amount can be used to cover the cost of insurance. Additionally, you can make withdrawals if needed, though taxes may be applicable. Importantly, you are not required to make an insurance premium payment every year, but you must ensure there is enough money in the cash value fund to cover the insurance cost.

The insurer must pay a 15% tax on the investment income generated within your cash value fund. Although you don’t pay this tax directly, it may be reflected in the fees charged by the insurer. Additionally, when you make withdrawals, you might owe taxes. If this is the case, the 15% tax on investment income paid by the insurer can be refunded to them.

IV. Disability Insurance

Disability refers to the inability to perform your job or a similar job due to illness or accident. Common causes of disability include heart attacks and mental health issues. The specific definition of disability is outlined in your insurance policy.

Disability insurance covers your mortgage payments for the entire duration of your disability. This means you won’t have to dip into your savings or incur debt to maintain your lifestyle, allowing you to focus on your recovery rather than your finances. The protection lasts as long as your disability does, which could potentially cover the entire repayment period of your loan.

In the event of death, the remaining balance of your mortgage is paid off either partially or fully, depending on your coverage. This relieves your estate from the burden of this debt. An additional benefit is that the cost of insurance decreases as the balance of your mortgage is paid down over the term. Essentially, you’ll pay a premium that is proportional to the remaining amount of your loan, based on the coverage you have chosen.

Thanks for reading! You can support my work by buying me a coffee.